Skip to content
>Resources>Recruiting & Hiring>The Teacher Shortage: Challenges and Long-Term Solutions 
Recruiting & Hiring

The Teacher Shortage: Challenges and Long-Term Solutions 

Share article

The teacher shortage continues to challenge K-12 school districts across the country, with many struggling to fill vacant teaching positions. According to our latest K-12 Lens Survey, which collected responses from over 700 administrators across the U.S., 81% of respondents are experiencing staffing shortages, and 67% report that recruiting and hiring has become more difficult in the last year.  

While these national statistics emphasize the scope of the issue, the reality in your district may vary. That’s why it’s critical to explore district-specific data alongside broader national trends when addressing the teacher shortage. Effective solutions require not only immediate fixes but also strategic, long-term approaches to build a sustainable teacher pipeline.  

In this post, we’ll explore how K-12 administrators can combat teacher shortages by focusing on teacher retention, leveraging data analytics, implementing Grow-Your-Own teacher programs, and more. 

The Current State of the Teacher Shortage 

The teacher shortage has intensified over recent years, but its roots run deeper. Research estimates there are currently 55,000 vacant teacher positions, though the actual number may be even higher. Additionally, the National Education Association (NEA) survey revealed that 55% of teachers are considering leaving the profession earlier than planned, citing burnout, low pay, and lack of support as key reasons. This combination of high turnover and a shrinking pool of candidates has created a pressing need for innovative, long-term solutions. 

“There are too few teachers entering the profession. We are short staffed, so teachers are covering multiple classrooms at a time. Each and every day there is a coverage plan as we lack the staff needed to provide the level of instruction and staff-to-student ratio recommended. Teachers are constantly being asked to do more for low pay. They’re getting burned out and leaving the profession.”

– Anonymous respondent, K-12 Lens Survey 

key stats at a glance:

  • 81% of districts are experiencing staffing shortages 
  • 67% of respondents reported recruiting and hiring has become more difficult
  • There are an estimated 55,000 vacancies for teacher positions 
  • 55% of teachers are considering leaving the professional earlier than planned 

Hand-picked content for you:

Analyzing the Teacher Shortage by Region

Download Your Region’s Report

Retention Through Support and Professional Development 

One of the most effective solutions to the teacher shortage is to retain the talented educators already working in schools. Research shows that high teacher turnover exacerbates the shortage, costing districts both time and resources. Here are some key retention strategies that administrators can implement: 

  • Mentorship Programs: Nearly 80% of districts agree that mentoring is the most effective PD offering for supporting teacher retention. In fact, 92% of teachers who have a mentor are more likely to stay in their district for a second year. Mentorship programs provide invaluable support to new teachers, offering guidance and connection that significantly reduce the risk of early burnout, helping them thrive in their first critical years. 
  • Personalized Professional Development: Our K-12 Lens Survey revealed 96% believe professional development will lead to greater retention. By offering tailored learning opportunities based on classroom performance and teacher evaluations, districts can foster growth, motivation, and a sense of purpose among educators. 

Click to Tweet This:  

“Want to retain more teachers? Personalized professional development and mentorship programs can reduce teacher turnover and make a lasting impacting. #K12Leadership #TeacherShortage”

Click To Tweet
  • Blended Learning: Offering Blended Learning for PD provides teachers with more autonomy in their professional growth. Giving educators voice and choice—the ability to select from various PD opportunities based on their interests, needs, and schedules—leads to greater engagement and satisfaction 
  • Teacher Wellness and Recognition: Teacher wellness programs and formal recognition can decrease burnout and increase job satisfaction. Simple initiatives like mental health resources, teacher recognition, and flexible schedules can positively impact retention. 

key stats at a glance:

  • 80% believe mentoring is the most effective form of PD 
  • 92% of teachers with a mentor are more likely to stay a second year 
  • 96% believe PD will lead to greater retention 

Hand-picked content:

How One of the Nation’s Largest 50 School Districts Built a Successful Mentor Program

Read Now

Grow-Your-Own Programs: Building a Sustainable Pipeline 

Grow-your-own (GYO) programs recruit future educators from within the district, targeting high school students, paraprofessionals, and community members. 

  • Partnerships with Higher Education: Collaborating with local colleges to create teacher education programs for high school students has proven successful. Educators Rising’s GYO program found that 81% of students in the program remained in the professional for at least three years.  
  • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DE&I): Programs like Illinois’ Grow Your Own Teachers are making strides in diversifying the educator workforce. Over 70% of the program’s participants identify as people of color, compared to fewer than 30% of Illinois’ overall teacher candidates. By fostering a more diverse teacher pipeline, districts can better reflect and serve their student populations, while also contributing to long-term retention and equity in education. 
  • Career Pathways for Paraprofessionals: Establishing clear career pathways for paraprofessionals to transition into teaching roles is another way to strengthen your pipeline. In Georgia, paraprofessionals can receive up to $6,000 in grant funds from the GaDOE to help cover costs of pursuing a degree in education. 

Hand-picked content:

How to Grow Your Own Teacher Pipeline

Get the Visual Guide

Leveraging Data for Informed Decisions 

Data-driven decision-making is essential for creating targeted strategies to address the teacher shortage. By analyzing workforce trends, districts can develop proactive retention and recruitment initiatives. 

  • Workforce Analytics for Predicting Attrition: Data tools that track teacher performance, job satisfaction, and risk of turnover allow administrators to identify at-risk teachers and intervene early. Districts using predictive analytics will likely experience a reduction in turnover after implementing data-driven retention strategies. 
  • Strategic Staffing and Resource Allocation: Data can help administrators identify which schools and subjects face the most significant challenges, allowing them to allocate resources strategically. According to our K-12 Lens Survey, Special Education has been the hardest role to fill in the past year, highlighting the need for targeted staffing solutions in critical areas. 

Hand-picked content:

How One School District Uses Data Analytics to Improve Hiring Practices

Read Now

Community Engagement and Financial Flexibility 

Teachers who feel supported by their communities are more likely to remain in their roles, while strategies like flexible access to pay can improve long-term retention. 

  • Community Partnerships: Districts that engage local businesses, parents, and organizations in supporting teachers often see improved retention. Initiatives like classroom sponsorships or volunteer programs foster a sense of belonging.  
  • Financial Wellness Opportunities: Offering daily access to earned wages for all district employees, Solutions like Frontline Flex Pay removes the wait for traditional payday, enhancing financial security and empowering employees to manage their finances with ease. This flexibility can lead to greater job satisfaction and long-term retention by reducing financial stress for educators. In fact, nearly 60% of employees report they’re less likely to search for new employment when offered flex pay options. 

Hand-picked content:

How Marion ISD Competes for Talent with Frontline Flex Pay

Read Now

By focusing on retaining current staff, building internal pipelines through Grow-Your-Own programs, and using data to make informed decisions, K-12 administrators can create a resilient teaching workforce. These strategies not only help fill vacancies but also create a positive work environment where educators feel valued, supported, and empowered to thrive. 

Ready to combat the teacher shortage in your district? Learn more about Frontline Recruiting & Hiring today. 

Talk to a Frontliner

Erin Shelton

Erin is a writer and member of the award-winning content team at Frontline Education. With experience in education, she is passionate about creating content that helps to support and impact the growth of both students and teachers.

Related Articles

Explore all articles